Massive industry stars didn't just appear to sign autographs at PWS events. Many of wrestling's biggest names have competed in the PWS ring.
This list includes The Great Muta, Jushin Liger, Mil Mascaras,
2 Cold Scorpio, Abyss, Balls Mahoney, Brodus Clay, Brutus Beefcake, Buff Bagwell, BWO, Butterbean, Carlito, Dan Severn, Demolition, Disco Inferno, The Dudley Boys, EC3, Elijah Burke, Gangrel, Goldust, Greg Valentine, Hacksaw Jim Duggan, Hurricane Helms, Jake "The Snake" Roberts, Jeff Jarrett, Justin Credible, Kamala, Koko B Ware, "The Genius" Lanny Poffo, Larry Zbyzsko, Marty Jannetty,Matt Hardy, Mr. Kennedy, Nasty Boys, New Age Outlaws, New Jack, Psycho Sid, Powers of Pain, Rey Mysterio, Rhino, Rock N Roll Express, Rikishi, RVD, Sabu, Sandman, Scott Steiner, Sgt. Slaughter, "Dr Death" Steve Williams, Tito Santana, Tommy Dreamer, Vampiro, Vader, and more.
PWS became known for often booking recently released WWE stars for their first post-television appearance. These wrestlers include Paul Birchill, Mason Ryan, Brian Myers, Tyler Reks, PJ Black, Trent Baretta, and Harry Smith amongst others.
PWS also enjoyed booking wrestling veterans that would reprise a former character gimmick they hadn't portrayed since doing so for WWE or WCW. Often these stars would be paired against each other, such as Bill Irwin as "The Goon" versus Tony Atlas as "Black Superman" and "El Matador" Tito Santana versus Mantaur.'
Other first-time-appearances since WWE/WCW have included Papa Shango, The Shock Master, "Young Stallion" Jim Powers, NWO Vincent, "Rap Master" PN News, The ECW Zombie, Glacier, and Phantasio. PWS also hosted the first-time reunions of 3 members of D-Generation X, Harlem Heat, and The BWO.
Several ECW alumni had their Retirement Matches at PWS including Justin Credible, Chris Chetti, and New Jack. Jerry Lynn's final wrestling Singles Match occurred at PWS, opposite Lance Storm.
The popularity of PWS' female division, led to the womens wrestling promotion PWS Bombshells, which held regular live events in New Jersey.
In addition to PWS' larger monthly events, the promotion held additional events at venues in parts of New York including Brooklyn, Long Island, Queens, and Westchester County. PWS also regularly held fundraiser events at multiple Knights of Columbus facilities in NJ and regular outdoor shows for various groups including street fairs, festivals, and private events.